A fight on a night out is a common way for a visitor to end up in a Spanish courtroom. The Interior Ministry's crime statistics for 2025 (Balance de Criminalidad) recorded 1,224 offences of injury and affray in the province of Málaga, 7.3 % more than the previous year. On the coast, the typical case starts late at night outside a bar in places such as Puerto Banús, Fuengirola's seafront, Puerto Marina in Benalmádena or central Torremolinos.
Spanish law classifies these incidents mainly by the result, not by the intention. The key question is a medical one: did the injury require treatment beyond first aid?
How Spanish law grades an injury: from a slap to grievous harm
| What happened | Article of the Criminal Code | Penalty |
|---|---|---|
| A push or blow that caused no injury | 147.3 | Fine of 1 to 2 months; only on the victim's complaint |
| Injury needing only first aid (a bruise, a graze) | 147.2 | Fine of 1 to 3 months; only on the victim's complaint |
| Injury needing medical or surgical treatment (stitches, a splint, a broken nose reset) | 147.1 | 3 months to 3 years' prison, or a fine of 6 to 12 months |
| The same, with a weapon or dangerous object, or with cruelty or treachery | 148.1 and 148.2 | May be raised to 2 to 5 years' prison |
| Loss or uselessness of a non-principal organ, or a disfigurement | 150 | 3 to 6 years' prison |
| Loss of a principal organ, a sense, or serious disfigurement | 149 | 6 to 12 years' prison |
| A group brawl using dangerous means | 154 | 3 months to 1 year's prison, or a fine of 6 to 24 months |
Two details explain many outcomes. First, article 147.1 states that simple monitoring of how an injury heals is not "treatment". Stitches, immobilisation or surgery are. Second, article 148 says the aggravated penalty "may" be imposed: it is not automatic. The court weighs the result and the risk actually created, which leaves room for argument when a bottle or glass was involved but the injury was limited.
Two other situations change the picture completely. If a man injures or strikes a woman who is or was his partner, even a minor blow is a prison offence under article 153 and the case goes to the court section dealing with violence against women; other family members are protected by the same article. And using force against a police officer can be a separate offence of atentado (article 550) or of resisting an officer (article 556), with its own penalty.
Self-defence under article 20.4, and why it often fails
Article 20.4 exempts from liability a person who acts in defence of themselves or others if three requirements are met:
- An unlawful attackA real, current aggression. Insults or a threatening look are not enough.
- A reasonably necessary responseThe means used to stop or repel the attack must be rationally necessary, judged by what a reasonable person would have done in that situation.
- No sufficient provocationThe person defending must not have provoked the attack.
If the first requirement exists but one of the others is missing, the court can apply an "incomplete" defence as a mitigating circumstance (article 21.1), which lowers the penalty by one or two degrees (article 68). There is also a consolidated line of Supreme Court case law that denies self-defence in fights accepted by both sides: if you agreed to "step outside", the law treats both of you as aggressors.
Does being drunk reduce the sentence?
Rarely by itself. Article 20.2 exempts only a person in a state of full intoxication that prevented them from understanding what they were doing, and only if they did not drink in order to commit the offence or could not foresee it. That is exceptional and requires solid proof. A significant but partial intoxication can operate as an incomplete exemption under article 21.1, with a reduction of one or two degrees, but courts demand evidence of how impaired the person actually was: a breath or blood reading taken that night, medical notes, or consistent witness accounts. "I had been drinking all afternoon" is not enough. Serious addiction can be a separate mitigating circumstance (article 21.2). In practice, alcohol tends to explain a fight rather than excuse it, and the defence should only raise it where the evidence supports it.
CCTV decides more cases than witnesses. Bars, shops, hotels and town halls on the Costa del Sol have cameras, but footage is often overwritten within days. Ask your lawyer to request its preservation immediately.
A glass in Puerto Marina, Benalmádena
On a stag weekend, a 29-year-old from Bristol is punched twice by a man from another group outside a bar in Puerto Marina. He swings back holding the beer glass in his hand. The glass breaks and the other man needs eight stitches on the cheek and is left with a three-centimetre scar. Police arrest him and record an aggravated injury under article 148.1 because of the glass. At the duty court in Torremolinos he is released, and the prosecutor later asks for three years. The defence obtains the bar's CCTV, which shows the two punches, and a forensic report confirming the scar is small and not a serious disfigurement. Before trial he pays the injured man 4,500 € in compensation, a mitigating circumstance under article 21.5. At trial the court applies the basic offence of article 147.1 rather than the aggravated one, considering the limited result and that he was responding to an attack, and imposes nine months in prison, suspended because he has no record. Self-defence was not accepted in full because using the glass was not a necessary response to two punches.
Compensation: what the injured person can claim
A criminal conviction in Spain includes a ruling on civil liability: medical costs, days needed to recover, scars and other after-effects. Courts often use the statutory scale for road traffic injuries as a reference, though they are not bound by it. If you are convicted, you must pay. If you are found not guilty, there is normally no compensation to pay in the criminal case. Paying or depositing a reasonable sum before trial is a strategic decision: it can earn a mitigating circumstance and make the suspension of the sentence easier, but it should be agreed with your lawyer so it is not presented as an admission.
What to do in the days after a fight in Spain
- Get your own injuries examined at a health centre or hospital and keep the medical report (parte de lesiones). Your injuries are evidence too.
- Photograph injuries, torn clothing and the scene.
- Write down names and phone numbers of witnesses before they fly home.
- Ask your lawyer to request CCTV from the venue and nearby premises.
- Consider your own complaint if you were assaulted. A cross-complaint ensures the other side's conduct is investigated too.
Mistakes that make an assault case harder to defend
- Telling police "I just hit him back" before seeing the footage. That sentence will be read at trial.
- Contacting the injured person or their friends directly, which can be seen as pressure on a witness.
- Posting about the night on social media.
- Accepting a quick guilty plea when the footage might support self-defence, or rejecting a reasonable one when it clearly does not.
- Ignoring the summons for the trial after returning home.
A fight that ends with an arrest usually follows the route described in our page on being arrested in Marbella, and serious cases may involve a custody hearing. If you need advice after an incident anywhere on the Costa del Sol, call or WhatsApp Carlos Babot on +34 663 227 835, 24 hours a day.
Common questions: assault after a night out
The other man started it. Can I still be charged?
Yes. Being attacked first does not automatically clear you. Self-defence under article 20.4 also requires that your response was reasonably necessary and that you did not provoke the attack. If you kept hitting after the danger had passed, or you agreed to fight, the defence usually fails or only partly succeeds.
Can the case be dropped if the injured person withdraws the complaint?
Only for minor injuries and blows without injury under article 147.2 and 147.3, which need a complaint from the injured person and end if they expressly forgive before judgment. Injuries that required medical treatment are prosecuted by the public prosecutor whatever the victim wants, although an agreement on compensation still helps.
Does paying compensation before trial reduce the sentence?
It can. Article 21.5 of the Criminal Code treats repairing the damage, or reducing its effects, at any time before the trial as a mitigating circumstance. It is often decisive for obtaining a lower sentence and its suspension.
Can I go back to the UK before the trial?
Usually yes, if you are released and the court has not retained your passport or banned you from leaving Spain. You must give an address for notices and return for the hearings. Tell your lawyer before you travel.
Last reviewed: 2026-11-06. General information on Spanish law in force; it does not replace advice on your specific case.
Further reading
